Nice, just dug into the repo, thanks for open-sourcing it. The rubrics are sharp, and making every finding carry a quote and a rewrite is cool.
A few things I hit going through the repo from my POV (and my Claude):
The validator checks shape, not the rules. Score matching the weighted subscores, verdict matching the score, 3+ rewrites below PASS, evidence on every finding - none of that is enforced. The thesis-article example breaks a couple of them (2 and 1 rewrites on gates below 75) and still validates. A rules check on top of the schema would make “the evidence stays attached” true.
The deterministic engine is keyword-driven, so an agent that can see it will learn to write “CFO”, “CAC”, “career”, “framework”. The vanity fixture picks up the full critique credit just from “never been higher”. I’d keep it as a cheap pre-filter and hide it from the drafting agent.
Small one: audit.mjs still has the “runs server-side for paying Tier 2 / Tier 3 subscribers” header, which reads at odds with the open-source framing.
On your two questions:
Handoff: for me the marketer owns the inputs the agent can’t see: who it’s for, the KPI, and how it gets tracked. The agent drafts and runs the gates. The human looks at anything marked REVISE and anything where the engine and the LLM disagree, and every override gets logged with a reason. Those overrides become the calibration set the weights are missing today.
Biggest miss: Relevance and Performance, but both are mostly decided in the brief before any copy exists. In creator work the expensive misses are wrong audience fit and no way to measure it (no UTM, no code), and a text-only review catches both late. I’d run those two gates on the brief and Signal on the draft.
Thanks again for sharing and hoping my thoughts are useful/relevant. Keep shipping!